Written by Jeanne van der Kolk

The research of young scientists: What do people think about genetic modification?

The research of young scientists: What do people think about genetic modification?

Written by Jeanne van der Kolk on August 02, 2024. Photo by Anders Chau.

What do people think about genetic modification? How does society feel about it? Young researchers Anders Chau and Aarnav Anand conducted a study on the sentiment surrounding these new technologies, leading to surprising results. Read on for the findings of their research, which we've summarized for you. Alongside interesting outcomes, the study also raised more questions for potential follow-up research.

Young Scientist Competition

Anders Chau, 16 years old, was born in Hong Kong and has lived in Ireland for several years. He is interested in genetic modification and biotechnology and has conducted research in these fields. He learned about the history of genetic modification and its processes, as well as the basics of molecular biology. In Ireland, the fourth year of secondary school is called the Transition Year, focusing more on gaining experiences and learning in practice. Anders decided to participate in the BT Young Scientist Competition and Exhibition in 2024, one of the largest science competitions for secondary school students in Ireland, together with his friend Aarnav Anand. They are eager to share their findings with you.

"I wanted to do something related to genetic engineering but at the time I didn’t have enough knowledge or experience to even try to attempt designing my own genetic engineering experiment," says Anders. "So I decided to do a project on DIY genetic engeneering: assessing accessibility, ethics, and public sentiment." This allowed him to gain practical experience working with a DIY genetic modification kit and theoretical knowledge through research on various aspects of the topic.

Anders explains, "We also ended up choosing this specific project because the more we researched genetic engineering, the more we realized how advanced the technology is. This just led us to believe more that genetic engineering will be a big part of the near future of humanity, whether we like it or not. It's just a matter of time. We believe that this technology should not be banned or restricted but continually developed carefully, because we think that banning genetic engineering and related areas of research is a mistake. This is because banning human genetic engineering would lead to the science wandering off to a place with jurisdiction and rules that no one is uncomfortable with."

Respondent group

For their research on societal sentiment, they distributed questionnaires to different groups. The 260 respondents included secondary school students from the first to sixth grades (200), university students (50), and professors (10). Anders and Aarnav wanted to see if educational level influenced participants' views on genetic modification.

Results of the study

Overall, the people who participated in the study were positive but cautious about genetic modification. Most believed this technology should not be used for altering appearances and creating "designer babies" or making people superior. As some participants noted, it is not meant to create "Captain America."

Among students on a theoretical learning path (higher-educated), Anders and Aarnav observed differences in thinking compared to other participants. Their views on genetic technology were more thoughtful, structured, and well-founded.

Ethical objections on modifying humans

The study results showed many ethical objections to modifying human genes. Genetic modification could be used to enhance the human gene pool and create an ideal gene pool. The immediate question is what this ideal gene pool entails and the goal of creating it. Would it be used to prevent hereditary diseases? And if so, how should new hereditary diseases be prevented?

Expected and unexpected outcomes

The researchers' expectations were partly confirmed and partly not. There was a correlation between educational level and knowledge of genetic technology, awareness of CRISPR technology, practical experience with genetic technology, and whether genetic modification was viewed as natural or unnatural. As educational level rises, so does knowledge of genetic technology, awareness of CRISPR technology, and practical experience. Additionally, higher-educated people are more likely to see genetic modification as natural than those with a lower educational level.

Other expected correlations did not hold. There was no correlation between educational level and the overall sentiment about genetic modification or the interest in conducting genetic experiments.

Anders and Aarnav had expected that concerns would increase with higher educational levels, but the opposite was true. It appears that more knowledge of genetic modification leads to fewer concerns about using the technology in general.

Caution, but no concern

However, caution increases with educational level. Higher-educated individuals are more aware of the risks of misuse or abuse of genetic modification. How the technology is used, by whom, and for what purpose is important, though this does not lead to more concerns.

According to Anders and Aarnav, there is a correlation between educational level and the degree of caution regarding genetic modification. "It is likely that people are less cautious as educational level decreases," says Anders. "The group of participants with a doctoral degree are the most aware of genetic modification and also the most cautious group." It seems that those with a lower educational level are less aware of the risks of genetic modification.

Lack of knowledge in society

Anders believes there is a lack of knowledge about genetic modification in society. This could be due to the insufficient coverage of current topics in school lessons. Only when a student asks about it does attention get paid. Anders suggests it would be beneficial to have more discussions about genetic modification to increase knowledge on the subject in an accessible way.

Speaking

SpeakingAnders Chau
  • Aarnav Anand: “Participating in the BT Young Scientist thing was great. I met people and learnt a lot. I realized that science isn't just about doing experiments. It's also about telling people why it's important and there's a difference between understanding science on paper vs in reality. In reality if you understand you should be able to explain it a child. Overall, the BT Young Scientist was very good. I would recommend it to everyone as you learn a lot and it's also quite good for social interactions.”

  • Anders Chau: “I enjoyed the whole journey that I went through, and I learned a lot from this whole experience. It was very entertaining and interesting to say the least. I have also realized that there is a lot more to genetic engineering and molecular biology than I previously thought. It has unquestionably answered a lot of the questions that I had when I started. But I would say that it has brought up and raised more questions than it has answered. Also, like my friend Aarnav said, I would also definitely recommend getting involved in the BT Young Scientist Competition, or just any science competition, as it is a great experience.

More Information

The entire study can be found here onedrive BT Young Scientist.

Contact details Anders:

Instagram
Facebook
Discord: despicable000

Forget the coconuts: Choose your world or build your own paradise

I signed up for cryonics, a procedure that freezes people just after they die. People undergoing this procedure hope that science will reach the point where they can later be brought back to life and restored to a healthy and youthful state. Now, why do I want that, and how do I see the future? ## Life After Cryonic Sleep It’s impossible to predict what life will be like after my cryonic sleep. I can only fantasize about it. *What kind of world would I like to wake up to? To answer this question, I have asked the following sub-questions: What do I like about the world, and what is its essence? What do I dislike about it, or rather, what would I like differently*? I couldn’t have come up with the answer in 5 minutes. I’ve been thinking about this for years, and here’s my answe...

Artificial intelligence and copyright in balance

The rapid rise of artificial intelligence (AI) has brought technological advancements and unleashed a power struggle between online content publishers and companies developing AI systems. Publishers fear AI systems will "steal" their content, jeopardizing advertising revenue and website traffic. This has led to lawsuits, blockades, and other measures to force AI companies to comply with specific regulations. However, this legal tug-of-war is costly and hinders the development of AI, a technology that has much to offer us as a society. It is time to stop these confrontations and move toward a new model of collaboration that benefits both publishers and AI companies. ## The Fear of AI and Loss of Revenue Many publishers and content creators see AI as a threat. AI models, such as the langua...

DNA as a guide to prevent health problems

I had wanted to have my DNA tested for a long time to learn more about my genetic mutations and ancestry. In this way, I wanted to discover the weaknesses in my DNA profile and take preventive measures. That is why I had my DNA tested via 23andMe. I was full of anticipation and curiosity as I waited for the results. What if I had a mutation that could affect my life? What if I had a condition that I did not know I had? My tests yielded several results that caught my attention. We will discuss these in detail below. But first, a brief introduction to 23andMe. ## 23andMe 23andMe is a genetic testing service that gives users detailed insights into their genetic makeup. The service includes reports on ancestry, traits, and, most crucially, health predictions. The health reports analyze spec...

Meet ChatGPT, today's homework robot

The world of technology is constantly evolving and its impact can be felt in the classroom. The introduction of ChatGPT changes the way students learn. ChatGPT is a conversation-based AI platform that provides students with a natural, interactive learning experience. It helps students practice their writing and communication skills in a fun environment. ### Homework robot One of the many uses of ChatGPT is as a homework robot. A science fiction that has become reality. It can handle a wide range of writing tasks, including writing programs for the computer. His work is so indistinguishable from human work that it is time for change. ### Approach People have different opinions about the approach. Some believe that we should stick with the old system and catch cheaters. Punishmen...

Why Software Must Be Free

For decades, the software industry has operated on a foundational premise: code is a scarce intellectual property that can be locked behind paywalls, licensed, and monetized. Companies built moats out of proprietary codebases, and copyright laws served as the walls protecting them. Today, that entire paradigm is collapsing. We have entered an era where clinging to traditional software economics is not only obsolete, it is actively harmful to our technological progress and our planet. When software carries a hefty price tag or restrictive licensing terms, a strange economic friction occurs. Instead of adopting an existing, perfectly functional solution, organizations and individuals increasingly choose to build their own custom alternatives using AI. At first glance, this looks like empo...

Real democracy: Voting on issues instead of people

Democracy is an excellent means of giving a country direction and taking different interests into account. When I first heard about this topic as a kid, I thought, “Wow, that's amazing!” But I also had my doubts. Why can you only vote for a person and not a subject? This could be so much better! ## Nasty political games I get a bad feeling when I hear the word politics. Don't get me wrong: the topic is super important! Too often I see abuse and wrong and personal interests taking precedence. I see through these dirty political games and it makes me sick. ## Back to the Essence This year I learned about direct democracy from Switzerland, which made me think about this topic again! These thoughts brought back the old ideas from my childhood, which were good thoughts after all...